How to Make Money
In Probably Stolen, make money early by flipping food and household goods and scavenging, then appraisals and the furnace, then water, wine, fish or batteries, and weapons late. Build one working business before buying more machines.
Early money in Probably Stolen comes from trading and scavenging, and KeenGamer's stage-by-stage order runs on through appraisals and the furnace to water, wine, fish, batteries and finally weapons.
Quick facts
| Early | Food and household trading, scavenging |
| Early to mid | Appraisals |
| Mid | Furnace production |
| Mid to late | Water, wine, fish farming, battery recharging |
| Late | Weapon manufacturing |
Trading
Buy from sellers below value and sell with your automatic retail markup, and take wholesale lots whenever you can place them: AllThingsHow bought a scrap pile for 64 and sold it for 92. See Bargaining for squeezing more. Upper Level Visitors pay the highest prices, and the customers you attract depend on Customers and Display Case.
Market events
Read the newspaper and calendar each morning. Water crises raise water prices, outages raise Energy Cell prices, and shady customers sell tips for 50. KeenGamer advises selling high-quality stock during a water spike, not clearing it beforehand.
Side income
- Appraisals: join the Appraiser Board for 85 credits; see Appraisals.
- Energy Cells: depleted cells bought cheap, charged and sold. TreyexGaming's playtest figure is about 1 credit per 100 kJ.
- Scratchers: up to 350 credits, from bartering and scavenging.
- Waste: the Corporate Waste Manager pays 100 credits per barrel.
- Dr. Jackson: he buys only materials, at prices that rise in a shortage.
- Bounties: the Wanted List totals 3,600 credits.
- Vending Machines: they keep selling overnight, though KeenGamer says the landlord's offer added 150 to weekly rent for disappointing sales and advises declining.
Dead stock
Rent day has its own buyers: GitM met a Supply Runner selling at 50% markup and a Merchant buying at a 15% discount. The Merchant's cut now depends on difficulty. TreyexGaming sells spare manuals and extra magnifying glasses to B4, as noted in the playtest.
Frequently asked questions
What is the fastest way to make money in Probably Stolen? There is no proven fastest way this early; KeenGamer's run moves from trading to appraisals, furnace work, water or fish, then weapons.
Is contraband worth it in Probably Stolen? It pays the best margins, GameSpew calls weapons and contraband the real money, but seizure costs you the goods, so KeenGamer tells beginners to avoid it.
Should I take the vending machine offer in Probably Stolen? KeenGamer's run declined the landlord's offer because it added 150 to weekly rent, though Vending Machines bought otherwise keep selling overnight.
Sources
- Probably Stolen: Complete Walkthrough & Beginner Tips, KeenGamer (Ali Amir), Oct 28, 2026
- Probably Stolen review, GameSpew (Kim Snaith), Oct 29, 2026
- Probably Stolen Beginner Guide: Running Day 1 and Saving to Pay Rent, AllThingsHow, Oct 29, 2026
- Probably Stolen Guide: Every Step From Day 1 to Buying the Store, AllThingsHow, Oct 29, 2026
- Every Customer and Visitor in Probably Stolen (Who Buys What), AllThingsHow, Oct 29, 2026
- Probably Stolen Beginner Guide - Tips and Tricks, TreyexGaming (Eric Langell), Sep 15, 2026
- Every Wanted List Bounty in Probably Stolen and How to Report Wanted Customers, AllThingsHow, Oct 29, 2026
- Probably Stolen is OUT NOW!, Questing Goose Studio and tinyBuild on Steam, Oct 28, 2026
- Probably Stolen tips: rent, contraband and fakes, GitM, Oct 30, 2026
- Hotfix - 1.0.0.1, Questing Goose Studio and tinyBuild on Steam, Oct 28, 2026
- I Ran A Sketchy Underground Shop - Probably Stolen, Aliensrock, Aug 3, 2026 (video)
Moments
I Ran A Sketchy Underground Shop - Probably Stolen
Aliensrock
See also
-
BargainingBargaining in Probably Stolen unlocks around Day 8. Offer Markup earns reputation; Demand Discount saves money and costs reputation; Blackmail works only on criminals; Threaten only on Augs.
-
Customers and Display CaseIn Probably Stolen, the display case brings buyers for what it shows, Neon Signs bring sellers, and Store Attractiveness runs from 0 to 1,000. Clean up to keep it up.
-
AppraisalsAppraising in Probably Stolen means valuing a customer's item from its guide for a fee. Join the Appraiser Board for 85 credits. GitM reports 20 credits' base pay, plus up to 15% for accuracy. -
Wanted ListProbably Stolen's Wanted poster has nine names worth 3,600 credits, from Lou at 1,500 to Arthur Lafleur at 100. Hold the teal Call Security button only when you are certain of the face. - AchievementsProbably Stolen has 21 Steam achievements, from Lower Levels Special for using the labeler to From Nothing, the Hard Way, held by 0.4% of players on Oct 31, 2026.
-
Beginners GuideStart Probably Stolen as the Apprentice on Mark Up, keep 200 credits back for rent on Day 7, stock food, inspect everything you buy, and only report a wanted face you are sure of.